Who Should Fire Your Managers
Scenario: "Dude, only upper management can fire managers. Yay! High-five!" Think of this 'oh-what-in-the-mutha' radical idea:
- What if basketball players could fire their coach?
- What if rap dancers could fire their choreographers?
- What if actors could fire their employees?
- What if employees could fire their managers?
What would happen?
- Stronger teams.
- Fattened accountability.
- Retention of kick-ass leaders.
- Kur-razzy financial results.
Most companies run pyramid hierarchies, giving the typical 'manager' freakish power over employees they manage; that destroys much incentive for that manager to serve employees efficiently. Instead, start enacting our beloved upside-down pyramid -- giving more power to those that actually affect the bottom line most.
Where Companies Go Wrong
In a typical company's manager-employee relationship:
- Manager: "You're not fattening the pipeline. Do it, or that's your butt."
- Employee -- saving face: "Okay, I will try my hardest again."
- Employee really thinks: "You're not providing sufficient resources, yo!"
When the manager sucks, the employee gets fired. And, that's a shame because most managers freakishly suck at their jobs -- leaving their potential superstar employees left to dry. (Just count how many ridiculously sucky managers you've had in the past.)
The Manager's Job
Manager Mikey's job isn't to serve upper-management; it's to serve his team's players. So, if the team players think he's leading them insufficiently, they can fire him -- and get another leader (within or outside the organization). The crazy effect that has on Mikey:
- "Oh !@#$! I better lead them efficiently, or it's my @ss!"
- "I can't slack off! Or, they'll get me!"
- "I better be sure I'm the best person for the job or else!"
Instead of resting on his laurels, Mikey starts diligently providing sufficient resources for his players to succeed. Yay for him.
"But wait! Is that all?!"
Nope; the hierarchy chain follows that sweet upside-down pyramid. Peep this:
- Manager Mikey's team players can fire him as their leader.
- Manager Mikey can fire his Superior Susie as his leader.
- Superior Susie can fire her higher-up as her leader.
- Yadda. Yadda. Yadda.
That ensures the right leaders are efficiently serving each and everyone of your people.
"Wait; but, wait! And who fires the employees?"
Build processes such that awesome employees thrive, and sucky employees drive themselves out the door -- quickly. We mentioned a method last week. Even better: have team players manage their peers -- such that if the team feels Billy is dead weight, they'll kick his booty out to conserve resources. (And even ten times better: let customers manage those front-line workers -- deciding who's staying, and who needs to go. That's the beauty of the upside-down pyramid.) That ensures every-freakin-body is serving everybody else. Yay your organization: Your workforce soon becomes super-optimized. When do you know you're your building a high-flying workforce? When a team of employees can tell their managers/leaders and peers:
'You fired, you lazy !@#$%-!@#. !@#$!'
Read More Business Tips From Trizle »
7 Comments
on Who Should Fire Your Managers
andhapp
2007-04-17 01:41:58 UTC
But in reality how many times does this happen...??? Give some examples...
The Trizle Team
2007-04-17 05:30:15 UTC
Hi andhapp,
W.L. Gore does that as well -- including us -- (as mentioned by Collins). That is, those who are managed get to choose their managers. If they're not good, then they can "fire" those managers and choose a new one.
Does that answer your question? Let me know!
-Andrew
Hendy Irawan
2007-04-18 02:44:03 UTC
Wow... this is really weird idea. Especially in a company...
I think it really can work, until the topmost of course... which is the largest shareholder. ;-)
I really agree with the idea that the front soldiers should be able to fire the CEO (assuming the CEO is a regular employee, not a 51% shareholder).
I'm not really good in the firing business, though ;-) Haven't even hired anyone :-P
andhapp
2007-04-18 07:43:26 UTC
Hmm....that is very interesting...
Have you got vacancies at Trizle..??? I would love to apply...
:o-)
Charlie
2007-04-18 19:51:39 UTC
I think that it's posible. If democracy have the power to throw down the person with the highest position which is the president, why not in companies? Everybody applied for their position, except for the owner.
Howie
2007-04-19 21:58:11 UTC
You have a good point. If they did something which can be a good reason for firing, why not? They certainly applied for the position like every employee does. We all have the right to choose our leader.
Pamela
2007-04-22 19:47:01 UTC
Some people with the right to fire a manager are blind about the situation. Managers are responsible for managing the team and it would be their fault if the team is not productive because they lack the skill.
Boost. Business. Knowledge.